Five matchdays of the 2025/26 Serie A season have already been enough to outline the league’s first major players.
Here is the complete Top 10 and the reasons why each of them earned a place of honor according to the Sofascore rating system.
1. Christian Pulišić – Milan (7.90)
The best player of the first five matchdays. The American has proven to be AC Milan’s true beacon, even when he’s not a starter: coming on as a substitute, he’s often changed the course of matches. Already decisive with the crucial goal against Napoli and the assist in the home win at San Siro, he combines consistency with the ability to make an impact in key moments (4 goals and 3 assists in 5 games). His rating reflects the overall impact he’s having this early season.
2. Nico Paz – Como (7.84)
Perhaps the most fascinating surprise of this season’s opening campaign. At 21, the Argentine talent is already Como’s technical leader: brilliant playmaker, personality, and top-notch moves (3 goals and 3 assists). In every match, he touches an impressive number of balls (64.6 touches per game on average), creates chances, and dictates the tempo like a veteran. It’s no coincidence that he’s already considered one of the most exciting prospects in the world, not just in Serie A.
3. Charles De Ketelaere – Atalanta (7.78)
Atalanta revitalized him some time ago, and he’s no longer a surprise. De Ketelaere has become a constant in the attacking game: assists, goals, and a lot of work “between the lines,” as the statistics clearly demonstrate. He’s found his ideal form, and the numbers confirm how indispensable he is today.
4. Alessandro Bastoni – Inter (7.68)
Among central defenders, few have had as much impact as him. His high rating rewards both his defensive reading, successful tackles, and clean runs with the ball, as well as his quality in build-up play, an aspect that makes him unique. Bastoni is now an absolute certainty for Chivu, and his performances rightfully place him among the best defenders.
5. Kenan Yildiz – Juventus (7.66)
The Turkish talent has taken Juventus by storm. In an attack where Tudor frequently rotates players, Yildiz is the only constant. Personality, dribbling, dangerous shots: his performances have always been above average. Consistency and offensive impact make him the most consistent of the Bianconeri up front.
6. Luka Modrić – Milan (7.66)
Forty years old and still going strong. The Croatian has amazed everyone with the intensity and desire he brings to every match. His performance against Napoli was emblematic, when Milan, down to ten men for the final thirty minutes, found in him a tireless leader: running, sacrifice, pressing, and a motivation he transmitted to his teammates. One goal, one assist, an average of 83 touches per game and two key passes per game are testament to the greatness of a champion who continues to make an impact on the biggest stages.
7. Matías Soulé – Roma (7.62)
With Dybala only partially fit, he’s the one who sparked the creativity of the Giallorossi attack. Soulé has proven decisive with individual plays, assists, and goals that have often unlocked tough matches. His rating is the result of successful dribbling, key passes, and consistent threat creation. He’s been a key player in Roma’s opening game.
8. Marco Carnesecchi – Atalanta (7.62)
The first and only goalkeeper in this Top 10. Carnesecchi further demonstrated his prowess in the last match against Juventus, where he was a veritable wall. Decisive saves, confidence between the posts, and the ability to play with his feet: his stats are among the best in Serie A for decisive saves.
9. Hakan Calhanoglu – Inter (7.58)
Calhanoglu led Inter with leadership and quality: impeccable playmaking, precise passing, and incisive set pieces. Over the first five matchdays, he stood out for his consistency, significant bonuses, and consistent performances, confirming his position as the fulcrum of the Nerazzurri’s midfield. And then, how could we forget his performance and brace against the Bianconeri in the Derby d’Italia?
10. Alexis Saelemaekers – Milan (7.52)
Saelemaekers surprised Milan with brilliant performances: running, sacrifice, and decisive runs made him a key player. In these first few games, he contributed with bonuses and quality plays, ensuring balance and unpredictability on the Rossoneri flank.
Sofascore’s Top 10 after five matchdays showcases a league packed with stars: from established leaders like Modrić, Bastoni, and Sommer, to emerging youngsters like Nico Paz and Yildiz. This mix reflects the diversity of Serie A: veterans who continue to teach the game and talents vying for the spotlight. The next few matchdays will reveal whether these ten players can maintain their elite status or whether new surprises will emerge and shake up the rankings.